“I’m not a designer, how can I critique design? What if I say something stupid?”
I know a lot of people who have this exact worry when working with a designer. You didn’t go to design school, you have no design degree so how can you pass judgement on typography and colour harmony?
Well, you don’t have to. Not really anyway. Your job is knowing your business and more importantly, knowing your audience. If you can shift your thinking into what people who visit your website will want to see and do then your feedback will be super valuable.
Start with why
Of course you will have an opinion on certain aspects of the design but before you say them try asking why it was created in the first place.
For example, say you have a personal vendetta against blue. Instead of saying “I don’t like blue, change it to green” try asking “Why did you choose to use blue here?”. Your designer should be able to justify their decisions and you can then evaluate whether you’re happy with their reasoning or not.
Describe the problem instead of prescribing the solution
Most of the time, telling designers what the problem is, is way more useful than asking them to move something or change something.
Going back to the colour example; saying something like “Blue is the colour of our main competitor so I’d rather not use it” is better than saying “Change blue to green” as it gives the designer a better understanding of what’s important to you and it gives them the opportunity to come up with something even better.
Go back to your goals
Remember those questions you answered in Getting an accurate quote? Dig these out and use them as reference for all of your feedback.
Is the project achieving the main goal it’s set out to? Or has a bunch of smaller goals been added, diluting your main task?
If you can use a short, specific goal or value to base your feedback on, you’ll find giving feedback is a lot easier.
For example, if you’re selling sunglasses for dogs, you’ll want to know if the designs are appealing to dog owners or if the progression from informing to selling is clear for your audience.
If you can relate every piece of feedback back to your main goal, you’ll find the project ends up being way more successful than a ton of subjective feedback.
Settle internal debates
If you’re working in a team, it’s important to try to settle any internal debates in-house before communicating them to your designer. By all means, ask your designer questions to help clarify but make sure you can come to an agreement before giving final feedback.
If possible, dedicate just 1 person to providing feedback so your designer doesn’t get in the awkward situation of actioning another team members feedback only to have the head of the project say “Why did you do that? Change it back” —it happens!
Speak up early if something is wrong
I’ve saved the most important thing until last. If you get your designs back and they weren’t what you were expecting or there is something fundamentally wrong, speak up as early on as possible.
Don’t worry about hurting any feelings. As long as you’re referring back to your goal at all times and not getting personal, there’s no reason for any tiptoeing.
Your designer should have the projects best interests at heart, so if it’s not right they will be happy to work with you to address the issues and get them solved. You can read more about this in the What to do if you’re not happy with the project article, but for now just know that the longer a project goes on, the more time consuming (and potentially expensive depending on your contract) those changes can get.
So there you go! Some ways you can give really super cool feedback when you see your designs. Just remember, you know your business and your customers - that makes your feedback the most valuable of all.